“I didn't steal any land”

an interview with Kallie Kriel

Guilt (Issue II/2019)


Mr. Kriel, extensive land reform is on the horizon in South Africa. The government of Cyril Ramaphosa wants to redistribute land that was taken away from black farmers during the colonial period and the apartheid. You are an outspoken opponent of the reform. Why?

I believe that the reform is just a pretext to redistribute valuable farmland from private into public property. The government has already bought around 4,000 farms, but only few of them have passed on to private ownership. Ramaphosa and the ANC are pretending to care about ethnic relations and economic justice, but in fact they want to make white farmers scapegoats and profit themselves. In fact, there are cases where officials have given land to party loyalists and even their own family members. But even if the process wasn’t corrupt it would still be problematic.

Why?

Because it would be a catastrophe if the government would expropriate white farmers and just passed it on to people who have not yet owned much land at all. To be successful in farming people need access to capital and proper education. That would have to be guaranteed first.

So, in your view, white farmers are more successful than black farmers and therefore nothing should change?

It has nothing to do with the colour of our skin. There are also black farmers in South Africa who own big agriculture businesses. But the land should not be handed to people who don’t have the knowhow to cultivate it. That happened in Zimbabwe in 2000 and there we saw food shortages and an uptick in unemployment as a result.

After the end of apartheid in 1994, 60,000 white farmers owned 86 percent of the farmland in South Africa. The remaining less fertile areas were owned by around 13 million black farmers. This distribution has not significantly changed since then. How are black famers supposed to succeed, if they don’t get to own land?

I am not saying that we don’t need a land reform in South Africa. I am simply criticizing its implementation.

That means you are in fact agreeing that there needs to be a process through which historical injustices towards South Africa’s black community could be rectified?

Well, every claim can be justified through history if you just choose a long enough time span. In fact, the first people who settled South Africa were the so-called Khoisan. However, these were later driven away by black Central Africans who migrated towards the South – and much later, in the 17th century, also by the Dutch. But the latter also settled on uninhabited land and purchased some of it from local tribes. So the South African history is more complicated than some want to make us believe. I did not steal land and other white farmers today have not stolen land themselves either. You cannot collectively punish them. Also, nothing has been taken away from the black farmers of the present day.

But surely crimes of the past do have a real economic and social impact on the lives of the ancestors of the victims, wouldn’t you agree?

That would need to be verified in each case individually. If someone can prove that the land of his ancestors was unrightfully taken away then there has to be financial compensation. But there should not be any arbitrary expropriations of white farmers who have done nothing wrong.

an interview by Kai Schnier



similar articles

Guilt (Topic: Guilt)

The greatest crime

by Hille Norden

When he was 14 years old, Soun Rottana was kidnapped and became a child soldier for Cambodia’s Khmer Rouge, killing dozens of enemy combatants.

more


Guilt (Topic: Guilt)

Self control replaces obedience

by Alain Ehrenberg

In the past, society made us feel guilty. Today we do it ourselves.

more


Poorest nation, richest nation

A country sinks into violence

a photo series by William Daniels

Utter poverty amid a wealth of resources has been the reality in the Central African Republic for decades. How did the country become the poorest in the world even though it abounds with gold, diamonds and uranium?

more


Guilt (Topic: Guilt)

“I didn't steal any land”

an interview with Kallie Kriel

Kallie Kriel, who represents the interests of European farmers in South Africa, considers land reform to be unjust.

more


Guilt (Topic: Guilt)

The eternal injustice

by Malaika Mahlatsi

Following the end of apartheid, the land question looms large in South Africa: What will happen to arable land that was taken away from the black population? The government now wants to reverse the theft by implementing land reform.

more


Guilt (Topic: Guilt)

Questions of conscience

by Ayelet Gundar-Goshen

Why do people feel guilt? An investigation into this basic human emotion.

more